Hello dear
Welcome To Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Story Hill
Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Story Hill is a beloved pizza destination located at 5300 W Blue Mound Rd, offering a delightful array of specialty pies and classic slices. Known for their late-night hours and reasonable prices, this pizzeria has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike. Signature options like the Mac n Cheese pizza and Smokey the Bandit highlight their creative approach, while the friendly service ensures a warm dining experience. Although parking can be a challenge on busy game days, the delicious and satisfying offerings make Ian's a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts in Milwaukee.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Cheese or Pepperoni
US$3.50Veggies and Fruits Mix Ins
Other
Vegan Options
Southwest
US$3.75Wisco
US$5.25Greek
US$4.75House
US$4.25Cesear
US$3.75 About
Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Story Hill
Welcome to Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Story Hill, located at 5300 W Blue Mound Rd, Milwaukee, WI. This beloved local gem has carved out a niche in the pizza scene, catering to both die-hard New York style enthusiasts and casual diners looking for a delicious slice. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by this vibrant spot.
As soon as you step into Ian's, you’ll notice the energetic vibe and the tantalizing aroma wafting from the kitchen. The menu features a diverse selection of pizzas, made with fresh ingredients and imaginative toppings. Customers rave about the Mac n Cheese pizza, a creamy and fulfilling option that has quickly become a fan favorite. But the creativity doesn’t stop there—try the Smokey the Bandit or the Italian Beef for a truly unique experience. Each specialty slice showcases an attention to flavor that sets Ian's apart from typical pizza joints.
The service at Ian's Pizza is consistently highlighted for its warmth and efficiency. It’s refreshing to see a team dedicated to creating a welcoming atmosphere, making each visit feel special. However, keep in mind that parking can be a challenge, especially on days when there are Brewers games—so strategize your visit!
Reviews from patrons like Anetta Beckwith and Jason Klingler underlie the strong community connection this establishment has built. Anetta praises the great pizza and reliable service, while Jason emphasizes the convenience of late-night hours and reasonable prices. Then there’s Jim R, who asserts that Ian’s is the best spot for NY style pizza in Milwaukee, complimenting their distinct specialty slices and salads. If you’re seeking a quick and affordable meal, as Gina Theesfield states, Ian's comes highly recommended.
In closing, Ian's Pizza Milwaukee Story Hill is not just a dining destination—it’s a celebration of creativity, community, and delicious food. Whether you’re indulging in a classic or trying one of their inventive offerings, you’re bound to leave satisfied and looking forward to your next visit. So grab a slice, enjoy the friendly atmosphere, and make memories at Ian's!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Ian's has great pizza. The service is always good. The only downside to this location is that there's only street parking. If there is a Brewers game on the day you want Ian's, there is absolutely NO where to park. ”
“ If you’re looking for some great slices of pizza, this is the place. My favorite is their Mac n cheese pizza. Every time we venture to Milwaukee we make sure a stop at Ian’s is in order. They are also open late and the prices are very reasonable. ”
“ As a die hard NY style pizza fan, this is as close as you’re going to get in Milwaukee. I generally love a basic slice, but Ian’s specialty slices are always outstanding—in particular Smokey the Bandit (always available), Eternal Hamnation, and Italian Beef. The salads are great and the service is always friendly. ”
“ There are 2 Ian’s pizza in Milwaukee. My son and I went to the Mets game on Sunday and he recommended Ian’s because he had it once before and it’s hard to find good pizza in Wisconsin coming from Long Island. We stopped and the bigger one for lunch and it was just as described, fantastic! The second one was closer to the stadium and was much smaller but just as good. ”
“ Quick, affordable, delicious! Our fav pizza place in Milwaukee. ”
“ Just stopped by for a quick slice (6:30 on a Friday). They were super busy but the entire staff was super friendly and efficient! They were pumping out orders in less than 5 minutes, and the food was hot and good. Great job Ian's Storey Hill! ”
“ Huge selection here. Many people picking up. A bit of chaos behind the counter. I had three slices. ”
“ Ian’s Pizza is always a win. Every time I’m in Milwaukee, I make a point to stop in. The flavor combos are insane (in the best way), and the quality is consistently amazing. You can’t go wrong with the classics, but the mac and cheese slice?? Game changer. It’s the perfect late-night bite, quick lunch, or casual hangout spot. The staff is friendly, the vibe is chill, and everything is super fresh. Never disappoints! ”